Other Categories of Decisions: Appellate Body Reports :: WTO Panel Reports :: GATT Panel Reports :: Article 21.3(c) Arbitrations :: Article 25 Arbitrations :: Other Arbitrations

• Documents are all PDF files. To view them, you will need the free Acrobat Reader, which can be downloaded from Adobe.

• These decisions are published in their officially paginated format by Cambridge University Press in the Dispute Settlement Reports (DSRs). The DSR citations are provided in the table (with the exception of recently circulated awards which have not yet been published).

• The last column is a link to our Dispute Settlement Commentary for the decision, and is only accessible to subscribers.

• For scholarly commentary on the issue of Article 22.6, see Steve Charnovitz, The WTO's Problematic "Last Resort" Against Non-Compliance.  This paper is based on an article originally written for and published in Aussenwirtschaft, December 2002.  The paper has since been revised, as of August 14, 2003.

Article 22.6 Arbitration Decisions

• Click on the column headings "Decision", "Member Requesting Retaliation", "Circulation", or "DSB Authorization for Suspension" to sort table by that column.

Decision Member Requesting Retaliation DS Number Circulation DSB Authorization for Suspension  Arbitrators Award DSC U.S. - 1916 Act (22.6) European Communities 136 Feb 24, 2004   Grcar, McGivern, Piontek Amount of Final Judgments and Settlement Awards under the 1916 Act DSC EC - Bananas (22.6)(U.S.) United States 27 Apr 09, 1999 Apr 19, 1999 Harbinson, Anderson, Haeberli US$191.4 million per year DSC EC - Hormones (22.6)(U.S.) United States 26 Jul 12, 1999 Jul 26, 1999 Cottier, Palecka, Yokota US$116.8 million per year DSC EC - Hormones (22.6)(Canada) Canada 48 Jul 12, 1999 Jul 26, 1999 Cottier, Palecka, Yokota C$11.3 million per year DSC EC - Bananas (22.6)(Ecuador) Ecuador 27 Mar 24, 2000 May 18, 2000 Harbinson, Anderson, Haeberli US$201.6 million per year DSC Brazil - Aircraft (22.6) Canada 46 Aug 28, 2000 Dec 12, 2000 Rosati, Shimizu, Sukhum C$344.2 million per year DSC Canada - Aircraft II (22.6) Brazil 222 Feb 17, 2003 Mar 18, 2003 Davey, Seung Wha Chang, Dwarka-Canabady US$247,797,000 DSC U.S. - FSC (22.6) European Communities 108 Aug 30, 2002 May 07, 2003 C. Falconer, Chambovey, Seung Wha Chang US$4,043 million per year DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(Canada) Canada 234 Aug 31, 2004 Nov 26, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(Brazil) Brazil 217 Aug 31, 2004 Nov 26, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(EC) European Communities 217 Aug 31, 2004 Nov 26, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(India) India 217 Aug 31, 2004 Nov 26, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(Japan) Japan 217 Aug 31, 2004 Nov 26, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(Korea) Korea 217 Aug 31, 2004 Nov 26, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(Mexico) Mexico 234 Aug 31, 2004 Nov 26, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Offset Act ("Byrd Amendment") (22.6)(Chile) Chile 217 Aug 31, 2004 Dec 17, 2004 Wasescha, Abdel-Fattah, W. Falconer Disbursements Multiplied by Coefficient DSC U.S. - Cotton Subsidies (22.6) (SCM 7.10) Brazil 267 Aug 31, 2009 Nov 19, 2009 Perez Motta, Matthews, Moulis US$147.3 million per year DSC U.S. - Cotton Subsidies (22.6) (SCM 4.11) Brazil 267 Aug 31, 2009 Nov 19, 2009 Perez Motta, Matthews, Moulis US$147.4 million for FY 2006; future years calculated based on formula DSC U.S. - Gambling Services (22.6) Antigua 285 Dec 21, 2007 Jan 28, 2013 Anell, Francke, Plasai US$21 million per year DSC Records: 19

 Copyright © 2009 WorldTradeLaw.net LLC